Jobs boards wish list – 10 years later review

On this very day a decade ago – in the very early days of doing my jobs newsletter – I wrote this list of improvements I would ❤️ to see to jobs boards as they were already starting to drive me a little bonkers.

Not gonna lie – a couple of them are really ‘of their time’ but most of them stand up I think.

So how do things look now?

[1] Vacancy per page

This is definitely much better – it is rare now just to have a single page the has a bunch of job ads/descriptions. Still happens but it is the exception not the rule.

[2] Cool URIs

No. Still rarer than hens teeth. I know nicely designed URIs went out of fashion – if they ever were in – but if anything things have gotten worse.

[3] Mobile first

This is still pretty inconsistent to be honest. Better for sure because so much of activity moved to mobile but it is still pretty clunky in a lot of places.

[4] Accessible

Not at all still. Poorly designed, poorly structured, inaccessible language, random inaccessible downloads.

[5] Schema.org jobPosting standard

This remains a real disappointment to me. It just never really got adopted at any kind of scale – maybe it will find its audience with all the AI bots trawling the web now.

[6] Enforce the dotEveryone Better Job Ads checklist

  • Is there a clear location for the job?
  • Is there a clear salary or salary range for the job?
  • Are there clear working hours?
  • Is there a creative commons licence permitting reuse?
  • Does the job description contain any gender-coded language?
  • What is the Flesch–Kincaid readability score for the job description?

I can’t find a link to the original dotEveryone Better Jobs work which is a shame because it was great and ahead of its time. Not much of this is common still though;
– locations ✅
– salaries (when the new law kicks in) ✅
– working hours ❌
– clear licenses ❌
– gender-coded language ❌
– readability ❌

[7] Smart, faceted site search (with subscriptions by email / RSS)

This has almost been and gone! Search was improving in a lot of places but increasingly it is replaced by weird and unreliable AI enabled search tools – which may someday be useful but for now…

[8] Archive of jobs ads after closing dates (hidden from Google)

Nope. Still incredibly rare. I still believe it would be incredibly useful but nobody else seems to agree!

[9] Links to employer Glassdoor profiles

This happens a little bit but Glassdoor has changed and been significantly ‘gamed’ in the interim period so not sure how useful it is now.

[10] User recommendations

I think this and the next one show what a Web 2.0 WNKR I still was at this point!

[11] Folksonomy / tagging

See above.

[12] Sign in to LinkedIn to see if you know anyone who works there

This isn’t a thing and nor should it be.

So in summary. 10 years have passed. I’m still doing the newsletter and things really have not improved much. What fun.

Leave a Reply